If you own a life insurance policy you no longer need, you may be looking at one simple number: the cash surrender value.
That number matters. But it may not be the only number that matters.
New 2025 market data from the Life Insurance Settlement Association shows that many policy owners who sold policies through LISA member companies received much more than the cash surrender value offered by the insurance company. That does not mean every policy qualifies. It does not mean every seller gets a large offer. But it does mean Florida policy owners should understand the secondary market before letting a policy lapse or surrendering it.
What the 2025 market data says
LISA reported that its members paid $626.6 million to consumers in 2025 for life insurance policies they no longer needed. The same release reported 2,955 completed transactions, a 9.48% increase over 2024. LISA also reported that consumers who sold policies through member companies received nearly nine times the cash surrender value, on average, compared with surrendering those policies to insurers. The average surrender value cited was $24,360, compared with an average life settlement payout of $212,066. Source: LISA release via PR Newswire, May 19, 2026.
Those are national industry numbers. They are not a Florida-specific guarantee. They also represent transactions completed through LISA member companies, not every policy reviewed in the market.
Still, the data points to a practical lesson: if your policy has real market value, surrendering it without a second opinion could leave money on the table.
Why surrender value and settlement value are different
Cash surrender value is the amount your insurance company offers if you give up the policy. It is based on the policy contract.
A life settlement is different. It is a sale to a third-party buyer. The buyer pays you now, then becomes responsible for future premiums and eventually receives the death benefit.
Because the buyer is evaluating the policy as an investment, the offer depends on several factors:
- Your age and health
- The policy death benefit
- The annual premium cost
- The type of policy
- The insurance carrier
- The policy’s cash surrender value
- Current buyer demand in the settlement market
That is why two policies with the same death benefit can receive very different offers.
For example, a $500,000 universal life policy with high premiums and no strong health change may receive little interest. A different $500,000 policy owned by an older insured with a shorter life expectancy and manageable premiums may attract stronger bids. These are examples only. A real valuation requires policy documents and medical underwriting.
What this means if you live in Florida
Florida policy owners have an important protection: life settlement activity is regulated.
Florida law uses the term “viatical settlement” in Chapter 626, even when many consumers would describe the transaction as a life settlement. Under Florida Statutes section 626.9912, a person may not perform the functions of a viatical settlement provider or enter into or solicit a viatical settlement contract without first obtaining a license from the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. Source: Florida Statutes section 626.9912.
Florida also requires important disclosures. Section 626.9923 says the seller must be told about possible alternatives, possible tax consequences, creditor issues, possible Medicaid or government-benefit effects, rescission rights, and escrow information. It also says Florida contracts must include an unconditional rescission provision allowing the seller to rescind within 15 days after receiving settlement proceeds, conditioned on returning the proceeds. Source: Florida Statutes section 626.9923.
In plain English, you should not be rushed. You should know who is involved. You should receive written disclosures. You should understand the effect on taxes, creditors, and benefits before signing.
The data does not mean every policy should be sold
A life settlement can be useful, but it is not always the best choice.
You may want to keep the policy if your family still needs the death benefit. You may have a loan or tax issue that changes the decision. You may qualify for an accelerated death benefit through the insurer if you have a serious illness. You may be able to reduce coverage, exchange the policy, or use other planning options.
Florida law specifically requires disclosure that alternatives may exist, including accelerated benefits for people with catastrophic or life-threatening illness. That point matters. A settlement review should compare options, not push one answer.
Watch the tax and benefit issues
Selling a life insurance policy can have tax consequences. The tax treatment depends on your basis in the policy, the cash surrender value, the sale price, and whether the transaction is a life settlement or a qualifying viatical settlement.
The IRS says death benefits paid to a beneficiary are generally not included in gross income, but that is not the same as selling a policy while the insured is alive. Source: IRS FAQ on life insurance proceeds. Florida’s required disclosures also warn that settlement proceeds could be taxable and that sellers should seek help from a personal tax advisor. Consult your tax advisor before accepting an offer.
You should also ask about Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income, and other needs-based benefits. A cash payment could affect eligibility. Florida’s disclosure statute specifically warns that settlement proceeds could affect Medicaid or other government benefits and says advice should be obtained from the appropriate agencies.
When a review makes sense
A policy review may be worth considering if any of these are true:
- Premiums are becoming hard to afford
- The original reason for the policy is gone
- Your children are financially independent
- A business need for the coverage has ended
- You are thinking about surrendering or lapsing the policy
- The policy has a death benefit of $100,000 or more
- Your health has changed since the policy was issued
A review does not obligate you to sell. It gives you another number to compare against surrender value, keeping the policy, reducing coverage, or other planning options.
The practical takeaway
The 2025 market data is not a promise. It is a signal.
Policy owners are receiving real money through regulated life settlement transactions, and the market appears to be growing. LISA reported almost 15,000 policies settled from 2021 through 2025 and $3.6 billion paid to consumers over that five-year period. Source: LISA release via PR Newswire.
If you are a Florida policy owner, the right move is not to assume your policy is worthless. The right move is to compare your options before you surrender, lapse, or keep paying premiums you no longer want to pay.
A licensed review can help you understand whether your policy has market value, what documents are needed, what protections apply, and what questions to ask before making a decision.
Get your free, no-obligation estimate
Source credit, disclaimer, and removal requests
This article is general educational life settlement commentary, not personal financial, tax, legal, insurance, Medicaid, or benefits advice. Life settlement eligibility, pricing, tax treatment, creditor issues, government benefit effects, and rescission rights depend on the policy, owner, insured, buyer, state law, and transaction documents. If you represent a cited source or a person, company, or organization referenced here and want a correction, credit change, or removal review, use the public contact page: https://selllifeinsurancepolicyflorida.com/contact/.